spare magazine

Should I Carry a Spare Magazine with My Carry Pistol?

Everyday Carry (EDC) enthusiasts often grapple with the question of whether or not to carry a spare magazine. Some may say that a spare magazine, containing additional ammunition for your carry pistol, can be a critical addition to your EDC, but it’s not without its pros and cons.

I have been in classes and parts of discussions where this topic can get quite heated. I’m going to look at this from both sides of the equation and try to be as fair as possible (basically because I believe the answer to this question is “it depends”).

In this article, we’ll dive deeper and explore the various reasons you should consider carrying a spare magazine, as well as the reasons why you might opt not to. Weighing these factors will help you make an informed decision on whether a spare magazine should be part of your daily carry.

Table of contents

Why You Should Consider Carrying a Spare Magazine

Carrying a spare magazine can offer several significant advantages for individuals who rely on firearms as a part of their daily lives. One of the most commonly used carriers for your spare magazine is the Neomag. What people like about it is that you don’t need to put your spare magazine on your waistline, and instead, you can put it in your pocket but still have the means to quickly grab it and reload your firearm if needed.

You could even run something like the T Rex Arms Sidecar Holster if you wanted to carry a spare magazine with your carry pistol.

Here are some reasons to consider including a spare magazine as part of your EDC:

1. Increased Ammunition Capacity

Having more rounds at your disposal can be a game-changer in a self-defense situation. A spare magazine provides you with extra ammunition, potentially doubling your capacity to defend yourself or others.

As they say, it’s better to have it and not need it than to need it and not have it. No one gets into a gunfight and says they wish they had fewer rounds.

2. Quick Reloads

Reload speed is a critical factor in self-defense scenarios. Spare magazines allow for faster reloading, reducing the time you are vulnerable during an engagement. This can be especially important when facing multiple threats or dealing with malfunctioning ammunition.

The below video is comical, however, if she carried one in the gun and then grabbed the spare, she’d be much better prepared…

“In a high-stress situation, seconds count. Having a spare magazine can make all the difference in ensuring your safety.” – John Smith, Firearms Instructor

3. Addressing Malfunctions

Firearms can experience malfunctions or failures to fire. In such cases, having a spare magazine on hand can be the difference between resolving the issue quickly or being left with a non-functional weapon.

Simply swapping out the magazine can often clear many common malfunctions. Why? Many malfunctions are due to issues with the magazine itself, not the firearm.

4. Versatility

Different situations may require varying levels of firepower. By carrying a spare magazine, you can adapt to changing circumstances. For example, you might carry a smaller, more concealed handgun with a single magazine for daily use but have a spare magazine for a larger, more potent firearm in your bag for specific situations.

For instance, many consider their carry pistol solely as a means to help them fall back to their primary — such as a rifle in their vehicle.

spare magazine

Why You May Choose Not to Carry a Spare Magazine

While there are undeniable advantages to carrying a spare magazine, it’s essential to consider the potential drawbacks and reasons why you might opt not to include one in your EDC:

1. Added Weight and Bulk

A spare magazine adds weight and bulk to your EDC setup. Depending on the size and weight of your chosen firearm and magazine, this extra burden can be uncomfortable or impractical for some individuals. Having a bunch of weight and bulk around your waistband can be a pain in the, well… back and hips.

2. Concealment Challenges

If you are carrying concealed, concealing a spare magazine can be challenging. The added bulk can lead to printing (visible outlines of the firearm or magazine through clothing), which may compromise your discretion. It can also limit your mobility and be painful if you constantly sit, bend, or crouch throughout the day.

spare magazine

3. Cost

Acquiring additional magazines can be costly, particularly for high-capacity firearms. The initial investment in firearms and accessories can add up quickly, making it a financial consideration for some individuals. That said, you’re wrong if you only have 1-2 magazines for your firearm.

Related Article: Are ETS Magazines Better Than Standard Glock Magazines?

In my opinion, you should have a minimum of four spare magazines. This allows for replacement if issues arise with some, as well as backups and the ability to load them up and hit the range rather than spending all day reloading magazines.

It’s crucial to be aware of local and state laws regarding magazine capacity and concealed carry. Some jurisdictions have restrictions on magazine capacity, and carrying a spare magazine may lead to legal complications. It’s essential to stay informed about the laws in your area to avoid any legal issues.

5. Statistics Don’t Favor It

If you were to do some research, you’d find that most “gunfights” don’t require a reload. In fact, most only have a few shots fired before everyone runs away. Your chances of getting into a gunfight and needing a reload are slim. In fact, I’d consider it a really bad day if you get into a fight and need a reload.

That said, the instances where reloads were necessary tend to be where police responded to a call, got in a gunfight, and sent an insane amount of hate in the direction of the criminal to stop the threat.

Finding the Right Balance

So, should you carry a spare magazine with your carry pistol? The answer is highly individual and depends on your unique circumstances and preferences. Here are some tips to help you make an informed decision:

1. Assess Your Needs

Consider your daily routines, potential threats in your environment, and your level of firearms proficiency. If you live or work in a high-crime area or have concerns about personal safety, carrying a spare magazine may be a wise choice.

2. Evaluate Comfort and Concealment

Think about the comfort and concealment of carrying a spare magazine. Experiment with different holsters (like the Neomag or some type of IWB mag carrier) and carry positions to find what works best for you. Balancing comfort with utility is crucial. Colder months tend to make the process easier as you can hide a spare magazine under your layers of clothing.

3. Stay Informed About Laws

Research and understand the laws in your area regarding magazine capacity and concealed carry. I am not a lawyer and am not giving you legal advice. Complying with local regulations is vital to avoid potential legal issues.

4. Practice and Training

If you choose to carry a spare magazine, dedicate time to training and practice. Familiarize yourself with reloading techniques and drills to ensure you can use your spare magazine effectively when needed.

Let’s Be Real… Carrying a Spare Magazine is a Personal Preference

The decision to carry a spare magazine with your carry pistol ultimately depends on your unique circumstances and preferences. There are valid reasons to do so, such as increased ammunition capacity, faster reloads, and addressing malfunctions. However, it’s essential to balance these advantages with potential drawbacks like added weight, concealment challenges, and legal restrictions.

Related Article: Is the Sig Sauer P365X the Best Concealed Carry Firearm?

Regardless of your choice, remember that your EDC setup should be an informed and deliberate decision, prioritizing safety and preparedness. Always stay up-to-date on laws and regulations in your area, seek proper training, and be responsible in your approach to carrying a spare magazine. Your safety and the safety of those around you should always be the top priority in any EDC decision.

Ultimately, as with any aspect of your EDC, it’s all about finding the right balance between preparedness and practicality to ensure that your everyday carry is tailored to your unique needs and circumstances. The only thing left to do is evaluate your circumstances and decide if carrying a spare magazine is something you want to do.

As a side note to close out this article, if you want to support our website and are in need of any tactical gear (or any product for that matter), anything you purchase using our links below will provide us with a small commission. We don’t charge for our free content and our goal is to keep it that way. We don’t have a Patreon account to put things behind a paywall, nor do we sell pics of our feet on OnlyFans. If you choose to use the links below and make a purchase (at no additional cost to you), we greatly appreciate your support as it helps us continue to publish free content (like this article) on our website:

And if you have a product you would like us to check out and potentially review, please contact us and let’s discuss.

supplement coupon codes
donate

*Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links or ads, which means we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you if you make a purchase through these links. These commissions help support the operation and maintenance of our website, allowing us to continue producing free valuable content. Your support is genuinely appreciated, whether you choose to use our links or not. Thank you for being a part of our community and enjoying our content.

PLEASE CONSIDER SHARING THIS ON YOUR SOCIAL MEDIA TO HELP OTHERS LEARN MORE ABOUT THIS TOPIC. SIMPLY CLICK BELOW!

Matt Weik

Matt Weik, BS, CPT, CSCS, CSN, is the Owner and Head Keyboard Banger of Weik Fitness. He is a well-respected, prolific writer with a global following and a self-proclaimed fitness and supplement nerd. Matt’s content has been featured on thousands of websites, 100+ magazines, and he has authored over a dozen published books.